October 23, 2026

Brazil’s Presidential Election: What’s at Stake for Environmental Defenders?

This is the fifth and last in a Climate Rights International series on what Brazil’s election could mean for the Amazon and the climate crisis.

Brazil’s presidential runoff on October 25 could have serious consequences for the people who defend the country’s forests, often at great personal risk.

 

Under Jair Bolsonaro, president from 2019 to 2022, weakened environmental enforcement and hostility toward those protecting the Amazon emboldened criminal networks and raised the risks facing defenders. President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has since rebuilt enforcement and taken steps to protect defenders, though many still face grave risks.

 

Lula’s challenger, Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, Jair Bolsonaro’s son, has pledged to rein in environmental agencies and proposed additional scrutiny of foreign-funded NGOs that take the federal government to court.

What’s at stake

Protecting Brazil’s forests has long depended on a wide range of environmental defenders, especially where state enforcement is thin or absent. Indigenous and other local communities monitor their territories and report illegal activity. Civil society groups help them document environmental crimes and the abuses they face, defend their rights, and press the authorities to act. Researchers and journalists find out who is destroying the forests and show where officials have failed to stop them.

 

Defenders often work in areas where conflicts over land and forests can turn violent. Since 2015, almost 400 people have been killed in rural conflicts over land and resources in the Amazon, many by individuals linked to illegal deforestation, according to the Pastoral Land Commission.

 

Those who expose or resist environmental crimes can face reprisals from criminal networks that use threats and killings to silence them. In 2022, for example, journalist Dom Phillips and Indigenous rights expert Bruno Pereira were murdered in the Javari Valley by men involved in illegal fishing. In a settlement near Novo Progresso, in Pará, several residents who denounced land grabbing and illegal logging have been killed in recent years. Such crimes often go uninvestigated, leaving those responsible unpunished and communities at continued risk.

Jair Bolsonaro’s record

Federal prosecutors told Human Rights Watch in 2019 that threats against forest defenders had increased since Jair Bolsonaro took office that year. Enforcement officials and local residents said illegal logging networks were operating more openly, and agents in the field faced threats and violence meant to obstruct their work. Prosecutors attributed the heightened danger to his weakening of environmental enforcement and his public disparagement of agencies and environmental groups.

 

Jair Bolsonaro repeatedly vilified civil society groups. In 2019, he accused NGOs, without evidence, of setting fires in the Amazon; in September 2020 he called NGOs working there a “cancer” that he had been unable to “kill.” His government cut civil society’s seats on the National Environmental Council from 22 to four and dissolved the steering committee of the Amazon Fund, which finances forest protection work by public agencies and civil society groups, removing NGOs from its governance.

Lula’s record

 Since returning to office in January 2023, Lula has rebuilt environmental agencies, hiring staff and restoring enforcement operations. He revived the Amazon Fund and restored civil society’s seats on the National Environmental Council.

 

In November 2025, Lula decreed a national plan to protect human rights defenders, including communities, environmentalists, and communicators. The same month, the Chamber of Deputies approved the Escazú Agreement, a regional treaty with obligations to protect environmental defenders, which his government had sent to Congress in 2023. It still awaits a vote in the Senate.

 

Yet many communities still lack effective protection. Residents of community conservation areas—such as extractive reserves, set aside for traditional communities to live in and sustainably use the forest—remain exposed to land invasions and violence. In research published in 2025, Climate Rights International found that community leaders in Pará who denounced illegal logging and mining had been threatened, and some had been forced to leave their homes. Insecure land rights, understaffed agencies, and impunity undermine both residents’ safety and the conservation these areas were meant to support.

The choice ahead

Lula’s reelection platform pledges to step up efforts to prevent rural violence and protect human rights and environmental defenders. It also promises to keep demarcating Indigenous territories and removing invaders, and to strengthen environmental enforcement. And it calls for greater public participation in policymaking. These pledges largely extend the policies of his current term, during which many communities have continued to lack adequate protection, particularly where forestland is contested and attacks go unpunished.

 

Flávio Bolsonaro’s platform singles out internationally funded NGOs that sue the federal government, proposing that they disclose their funders and projects. Targeting organizations because they challenge the government in court could discourage lawsuits that contest environmental licenses, demand enforcement, and defend Indigenous territories.

 

As president, he could also sign bills now before Congress. A proposed version of one, introduced in 2024 by a deputy from his Liberal Party (PL), would ban foreign funding, with narrow exceptions, and bar covered organizations from suing or sitting on government policy councils; that version has not been adopted. Another, introduced in the Senate in May 2026 by another party and still pending, would impose extensive auditing and disclosure requirements on foreign-funded groups that seek to influence public policy. Its author cited NGO lawsuits over a highway project in the Amazon as justification. The first could cut off money that many groups depend on; the second could burden them with compliance costs.

 

At an industry forum in Brasília in June, Flávio Bolsonaro criticized Ibama and ICMBio, the federal agencies responsible for environmental enforcement and protected areas, called for cutting their bureaucracy, and said the agencies’ “empire” had to end. A renewed retreat from enforcement would leave those who challenge illegal logging, mining, and land grabbing more exposed to threats and attacks.

 

Threats of invasion tied to a possible Flávio Bolsonaro victory are already reaching some communities. In October, Folha de S.Paulo reported that Parakanã communities in Pará’s Apyterewa Indigenous Territory had received audio messages from local residents describing ranchers’ plans to invade the territory if he won. The director of an organization that works in the region told Climate Rights International that its staff had heard of similar threats in several other communities.


Much of what this series has examined, from forest protection and Indigenous land rights to safeguards for major infrastructure projects, depends on the communities and environmentalists working to defend Brazil’s forests. Whether the next government strengthens or weakens environmental enforcement and civil society’s ability to act will help determine how safe they are and whether their work succeeds.

 

Read the other explainers in our Brazil election series.

Photo: Climate protests in Belém, State of Pará, Brazil. Credit: Mirna Wabi-Sabi / Unsplash. 

Like this article?

Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share by Email

Related Articles

RelatedArticles