Interview: Nickel mining is causing a disaster in Indonesia. Things can be done differently.

Originally published in NRC by Saskia Konniger

People who drive a silent, emission-free car through the streets have usually chosen an electric car because they want to contribute to solving the climate problem. Electric buses will also be operating in Belém, where the annual climate summit is taking place this month. But the mining of nickel, the raw material needed for car batteries, leads to deforestation, serious environmental pollution, and systematic human rights violations in Indonesia, says Krista Shennum, lead researcher of the Climate Rights International report “Does Anyone Care.”

“Electric transport is an important step in reducing fossil fuel emissions,” she says. “But the way nickel is currently being mined actually exacerbates the climate crisis.” In 2024, Indonesia exported nickel worth approximately $40 billion, half of all nickel in the world. The stakes are enormous. “Nickel could be part of the solution, but that’s not currently the case,” says the American environmental expert during a visit to Jakarta.

For three years, Shennum, who trained at Yale University, and a team of local researchers visited nickel mining areas in Sulawesi and the Moluccas. “Nickel is located just below the surface. Huge areas are being scraped off. This mining leads to large-scale deforestation, and forests are crucial for nitrogen storage.”

The nickel industry also leads to biodiversity loss. Environmental organizations have previously warned that 5,000 hectares of tropical forest, home to rare species, have been cleared in the Morowali region of Sulawesi.

The Moluccas boasts the largest nickel mine in the world. The Weda Bay Industrial Park covers an impressive 45,000 hectares. Here too, nickel is mined in open pits. And just like on Sulawesi, the nickel is smelted on-site for further processing.

“All Indonesian nickel smelters are powered by coal-fired power plants,” says Shennum. “These nickel-coal power plants produce the same amount of energy as Thailand and the Philippines combined. That’s insane. Publishing emissions reports isn’t mandatory. So we don’t even know how much air pollution the nickel industry causes.

The CRI report describes a series of gross human rights violations. The team found that serious air, water, and soil pollution is occurring everywhere. Communities that have lived from agriculture or fishing for generations have lost their income. Many people are sick. “I spoke with people in Morowali who had to replace their corrugated iron roofs every six months because they had eroded due to acid rain. In the nickel mining areas, residents no longer dare to touch surface water. “The water is coffee-brown. Fish have disappeared or look strange.”

Distributing face masks

The research team visited the fishing village of Tani Indah, located between a nickel smelter and a coal-fired power plant. “When they cut open the fish, it’s black inside,” says Shennum. “Everywhere we went, people had breathing problems or rashes.” Shennum confronted the mining companies with the findings. “We asked if they were taking local residents into account. In some cases, they are distributing face masks, but that’s obviously not a solution.”

There is also little information about water pollution. “The companies are required to test the groundwater and surface water around the mines, but they are not required to make the results public. People have to assess the water’s pollution themselves. Can I swim in it? Can we wash in it? Is the fish poisonous? People decide whether to use the water based on its smell and color.”

Sometimes, forced relocations result in new housing being offered. “On the Moluccan island of Obi, residents were relocated to a village called ‘EcoVillage.’ You’d expect a beautiful green environment, but one mother told me that a mountain of coal lay openly next to her children’s school.”

One euro per tree

“There are also so-called tailings ponds in the area, where the miners store their waste—water full of toxic metals. There’s no leakage monitoring.” Elsewhere, residential areas are being occupied by the industry without adequate compensation. “In Southeast Sulawesi, residents had to give up land they used to grow cashews. They received less than a euro per tree. Initially, they were happy with the money, because it was a significant sum for them. But after a year, the money ran out, and now they have no income.”

Dissent is punished. “In October, eleven people from the Moluccan Maba Sangaji community were sentenced to prison terms of two to five months for protesting the expansion of a nickel mine on ancestral land.”

According to Article 162, passed in 2020, obstruction of mining is prohibited. This includes protest. “In most mining areas, the army is deployed to protect the industry. I spoke to people who were visited by police or soldiers when they protested. They were threatened with losing government support. People feel sacrificed. These communities are paying the price for the global energy transition. For solving a climate crisis they did not cause.” CRI requested a response from various Indonesian ministries, but received no response.

Solutions

After three years of research in an apocalyptic environment, Shennum hasn’t lost hope. “Things can get better tomorrow,” she says firmly. Through more consultation with the local population, better compensation, and better pollution control. And through international pressure from buyers and investors. “I’m actually optimistic. Recently, a Norwegian state pension fund withdrew from Eramet, a French mining company active in the area, due to logging.”

And there are cleaner ways to process nickel. “That really doesn’t have to be done with coal-fired power plants. It can also be done with wind turbines.” She wants to focus on solutions. “People in the Global North have a responsibility to listen to these stories. So they can ask questions of the manufacturing companies and their governments. What are you doing about the consequences of the nickel industry?”

 

Translated via Google Translate.